The old "It's heritage, not racism" defense of the Confederate flag--again. And again. And again. Anyone interested in deconstructing that binary? Take a shot.
A
Confederate battle flag hung inside the old North Carolina State
Capitol last week to mark the sesquicentennial of the Civil War is being
taken down after civil rights leaders raised concerns.
The decision was announced Friday evening, hours after the Associated
Press published a story about the flag, which officials said was part
of an historical display intended to replicate how the antebellum
building appeared in 1863. The flag had been planned to hang in the
House chamber until April 2015, the 150th anniversary of the arrival of
federal troops in Raleigh.
“This is a temporary exhibit in an historic site, but I’ve learned
the governor’s administration is going to use the old House chamber as
working space,” Cultural Resources Secretary Susan Kluttz said Friday
night. “Given that information, this display will end this weekend
rather than April of 2015.”
Kim Genardo, the spokeswoman for Gov. Pat McCrory, said the exhibit
that includes the Confederate battle flag will be relocated, possibly
across the street to the N.C. Museum of History.
The decision was a quick about-face for the McCrory administration,
which initially defended the display. Many people see the flag as a
potent reminder of racial discrimination and bigotry.
State Historic Sites Director Keith Hardison had said Thursday the
flag should be viewed in what he called the proper historical context.
“Our goal is not to create issues,” said Hardison, a Civil War
re-enactor and history buff. “Our goal is to help people understand
issues of the past. … If you refuse to put something that someone might
object to or have a concern with in the exhibit, then you are basically
censoring history.”
North Carolina NAACP president Rev. William Barber was shocked Friday when he was shown a photo of the flag by the AP.
“He is right that it has a historical context,” Barber said. “But
what is that history? The history of racism. The history of lynchings.
The history of death. The history of slavery. If you say that shouldn’t
be offensive, then either you don’t know the history, or you are denying
the history.”
Barber couldn’t immediately be reached Friday night, after the decision to take down the flag.
Sessions of the General Assembly moved to a newer building a
half-century ago, but the old Capitol building is still routinely used
as a venue for official state government events. McCrory’s office is on
the first floor, as are the offices of his chief of staff and
communications staff.
The Republican governor was in the House chamber where the
Confederate flag hangs as recently as Thursday, when he presided over
the swearing-in ceremony of his new Highway Patrol commander.
The presentation of the Confederate battle flag at state government
buildings has long been an issue of debate throughout the South. For
more than a decade, the NAACP has urged its members to boycott South
Carolina because of that state’s display of the flag on the State House
grounds.
Prior to taking his current job in North Carolina in 2006, Hardison
worked as director at the Mississippi home of Confederate President
Jefferson Davis, which is operated as a museum and library owned by the
Sons of Confederate Veterans. The group has led the fight in the South
for the proud display of the Confederate flag, which it contends is a
symbol of heritage, not hate.
Hardison said the battle flag was displayed with other flags
described in the diary of a North Carolina woman who visited the Capitol
in 1863. A large U.S. flag displayed in the Senate chamber is
reminiscent of a trophy of war captured from Union troops at the Battle
of Plymouth.
“I thought, wouldn’t it be wonderful to recreate this?” Hardison
said. “I think we were all thinking along the same vein. … The Capitol
is both a working seat of government, in that the governor and his staff
has his office there. But it is also a museum.”
Hardison pointed out that the national flag used by the Confederate
government, with its circle of white stars and red and white stripes, is
still flown over the State Capitol dome each year on Confederate
Memorial Day. The more familiar blood-red battle flag, featuring a blue
“X” studded with white stars, was used by the rebel military.
David Goldfield, a history professor at the University of North
Carolina at Charlotte and author of the book “Still Fighting the Civil
War,” said the battle flag can hold starkly different meanings depending
on a person’s social perspective.
“The history of the Confederate battle flag, how it was designed and
formulated, how it has been used through the years, clearly states that
it is a flag of white supremacy,” Goldfield said. “I know current Sons
of Confederate Veterans would dispute that, saying ‘Hey, I’m not a
racist.’ But the fact remains that the battle flag was used by a country
that had as its foundation the protection and extension of human
bondage.” (AP)